American Idol Katy Perry: Why She Left After 7 Seasons

When Katy Perry took the American Idol stage in 2018, she joined a show that had already launched careers for two decades. Seven seasons later, she stepped away as the highest-paid female judge the series had ever seen. The numbers behind her departure reveal plenty about what it takes to sit in that judge’s chair—and what comes next for the show.

Seasons as Judge: 7 · Years on Show: 2018-2024 · Final Season: 22 · Co-Judges: Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie · Reason for Exit: New music projects

This key facts table summarizes the core data points about Perry’s seven-season tenure.

Why Did Katy Perry Leave American Idol?

Perry announced her departure in February 2024 during an appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live, months before Season 22 concluded. Her stated reason was straightforward: the show had consumed time she wanted to redirect toward her own music.

“I feel like I need to go out and feel that pulse to my own beat,” Perry said on Jimmy Kimmel Live in February 2024. She told Entertainment Tonight two months later that she was “just trying to make space for other things.”

Official Reasons

During her seven seasons on Idol, Perry released only one album: her sixth record “Smile” in August 2020. That single release in seven years stands in sharp contrast to her pre-Idol output of a new album roughly every two years. Show producers accepted her decision without friction—Perry emphasized her departure was not a retirement announcement but rather making space for other work opportunities.

Personal Projects

Lionel Richie, her co-judge throughout her tenure, offered context in an Entertainment Tonight interview: “She’s got a baby and she’s got a family, got new music, and it’s going to be amazing.”

Future Plans

Perry’s departure coincided with the birth of her daughter Daisy in August 2021 and ongoing relationship with Orlando Bloom. The $25 million per season salary (her earnings totaled $100 million after four seasons) meant financial pressure was not a factor—artistic fulfillment drove the decision.

The implication: Perry left roughly $50 million on the table by not returning for Season 23. Whether the music projects she planned justify that trade-off remains to be seen.

How Many Years Did Katy Perry Judge American Idol?

Perry served as an American Idol judge for seven complete seasons, joining when ABC revived the dormant franchise in 2018 and departing after Season 22 concluded in May 2024.

Season Breakdown

Her tenure spans Seasons 16 through 22 on ABC. The show originally aired on Fox from 2002 to 2016 before being revived by ABC. Perry entered during the show’s resurgence, helping rebuild ratings alongside Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie.

The season-by-season table below documents key milestones from her seven-season run.

Start and End Dates

Perry joined American Idol in 2018 when the series premiered on ABC. She announced her exit in February 2024, before Season 22 even began filming, making her final episode May 2024. This seven-season run placed her among the longer-serving judges in the franchise’s history.

The pattern: Perry’s departure came at a natural transition point. The show had stabilized under her tenure, and the 2026 season will mark the third year without her—a significant shift for longtime viewers.

Who Are the American Idol Judges for 2026?

Season 23 featured Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, and Carrie Underwood as the judging panel. For the 2026 season, ABC has confirmed that Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie will return, with Carrie Underwood continuing as the third judge.

Current Trio

The 2026 panel maintains continuity with Season 23. Luke Bryan, earning approximately $12 million per season, remains the highest-paid judge behind Perry’s former $25 million salary. Lionel Richie earns $10 million per season. Carrie Underwood’s compensation sits at $12.5 million per season.

Potential Changes

According to an ABC insider, Miley Cyrus was reportedly the network and producers’ first choice to replace Perry before negotiations with Underwood accelerated. ABC did not want to top Perry’s $25 million salary for her replacement, which shaped the final compensation structure offered to Underwood.

What this means: the Perry-to-Underwood transition represents a deliberate cost-cutting move by ABC. The network secured a major name (Underwood) for roughly half Perry’s rate, while maintaining two experienced judges for continuity.

Why Is Carrie Underwood’s American Idol Salary Half of Katy Perry’s?

Carrie Underwood earns approximately $12.5 million per season as an American Idol judge—exactly half of what Katy Perry made at $25 million per season.

Salary Details

Perry’s $25 million salary made her the highest-paid female judge in American Idol history, surpassing Mariah Carey and Jennifer Lopez, who both previously served in that role. After four seasons, Perry had already earned $100 million as a judge. The only judge who earned more per season was Simon Cowell, at $36 million per season during his tenure.

The table below places Underwood’s $12.5 million salary in context alongside the show’s other judges.

Negotiation Factors

ABC did not want to top Perry’s $25 million salary for her replacement, which directly shaped the compensation offered to Underwood. Perry’s massive salary was justified because ABC requested significant time away from her music career—a commitment Underwood did not negotiate at the same level.

The trade-off: Underwood brings her own credibility as a former contestant who won Season 4 in 2005, has released nine albums, headlined tours, and accumulated a net worth estimated at $120 million. Her value proposition differs from Perry’s—less star power for a more budget-friendly rate.

Was Katy Perry on American Idol?

Yes. Katy Perry served as a judge on American Idol from 2018 to 2024, spanning seven seasons across the show’s ABC revival.

Role as Judge

Perry judged alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan during her entire tenure. She was known for her enthusiastic support of contestants, memorable reactions, and occasional on-stage moments that generated social media discussion.

Notable Moments

During her seven seasons, Perry presided over thousands of auditions and guided contestants through live performance rounds. Her role extended beyond critique to mentorship, with producers noting her genuine investment in developing artists’ careers.

She’s got a baby and she’s got a family, got new music, and it’s going to be amazing.

— Lionel Richie, co-judge on American Idol

I feel like I need to go out and feel that pulse to my own beat.

— Katy Perry, on Jimmy Kimmel Live

What to watch: whether Perry returns for guest appearances or special episodes will signal whether her break from Idol is permanent or a temporary pause.

Related reading: Carrie Underwood’s “Before He Cheats” lyrics · Carrie Underwood Before He Cheats full lyrics

Katy Perry’s sharp instincts as a judge shone when she told contestant Benson Boone he could win American Idol.

Frequently asked questions