American Idol Katy Perry: Why She Left After 7 Seasons

Katy Perry bid farewell to American Idol in September 2024, telling Jimmy Kimmel Live viewers she needed to “go out and feel that pulse to my own beat.” Seven seasons later, she left behind a judging panel that had anchored the ABC revival since 2018—and a reported $25 million annual salary that had made her one of reality television’s highest-paid personalities.

Seasons as Judge: 7 · Years on Show: 2018-2024 · Co-Judges: Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie · Departure Year: 2024 · Salary Note: Double Carrie Underwood’s

Five key data points define Perry’s Idol tenure and its aftermath.

Why Did Katy Perry Leave American Idol?

Perry announced her departure on Jimmy Kimmel Live in February 2024, months before her final season even aired. She framed the exit in personal terms. “I feel like I need to go out and feel that pulse to my own beat,” she said during the appearance (TV Insider). In a separate interview with Entertainment Tonight in April 2024, she elaborated: “I’m just trying to make space for other things” (TV Insider).

The pattern is concrete: during her seven seasons on Idol, Perry released only one album. Her seventh studio album, “143,” arrived in September 2024, months after her final episode aired (TV Insider). The album received mixed reviews from critics and fans alike.

Perry announced the Lifetimes tour beginning in April 2026, with stops across North America, Australia, Europe, and South America, concluding in November 2026 (TV Insider). The tour schedule spans the period when American Idol would typically film its season, raising questions about any potential guest appearance.

How Many Years Did Katy Perry Judge American Idol?

Perry joined American Idol for its ABC reboot in season 16 (2018), sitting alongside Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie from the very first episode on the new network (American Songwriter). Lionel Richie publicly acknowledged her role as “one of the originators” of the ABC run (LA Times).

Her final episode aired in May 2024, when Abi Carter—a 21-year-old musician from Indio, California—won Season 22 (LA Times). That win capped a seven-season run spanning 2018 through 2024.

Start in season 16

The ABC revival positioned Perry as its headline judge, a role reflected in her compensation. She reportedly earned $25 million per year during her tenure—a figure that represented a large portion of the network’s budget when the show relaunched (TV Insider).

End in season 22

By the time Perry departed, she had become synonymous with the modern Idol era. Carrie Underwood—who won the competition in 2005—was announced as her replacement for Season 23 (TV Insider).

Who Are the American Idol Judges for 2026?

Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie have both confirmed their return for the upcoming season, keeping at least two-thirds of the original panel intact (TV Insider). Carrie Underwood’s status, however, remains unsettled.

Reports indicate Underwood may be seeking a higher salary for the 2026 season, potentially creating a rift with ABC over compensation (Geek Sided). American Idol 2026 is expected to premiere in February or March 2026, though no official announcement has confirmed the full panel (Geek Sided).

Why Is Carrie Underwood’s American Idol Salary Half of Katy Perry’s?

Perry earned $25 million annually as a judge—making her the highest-paid panelist on reality television during her tenure (TV Insider). Underwood, by contrast, earns an estimated $10 million to $12 million per season (TV Insider). Life & Style reported that Underwood makes approximately $12.5 million—roughly half of Perry’s former salary.

The gap reflects negotiation timing as much as star power. When the ABC revival launched, Perry was positioned as the centerpiece of the new panel, justifying a premium. Bryan and Richie, initially offered $2.5 million each, ultimately negotiated to $7 million per season after Perry’s deal was set (TV Insider). Bryan now earns an estimated $12 million annually, while Richie earns around $10 million.

“Perry was reportedly making $25 million per year during her seven seasons on American Idol.”

— TV Insider analysis of judge compensation structures

Underwood, who won American Idol in 2005, came to the panel as a former contestant rather than an external star—a different value proposition that shaped her initial contract. Her reported push for more money ahead of 2026 suggests she may be renegotiating that baseline.

Will Katy Perry Return to American Idol?

Perry has left the door open. During her final appearances, she teased a potential return, saying “Maybe I’ll come back if they’ll have me one day” (TV Insider). No formal offer has been reported.

The Lifetimes tour runs April through November 2026, covering periods when Idol would typically be in production. Any guest appearance would require scheduling around those commitments—a logistical hurdle that makes spontaneous returns unlikely.

The implication: Perry’s exit was designed for closure. Her music career takes priority, and a touring schedule that spans continents doesn’t easily accommodate episodic television appearances. Guest spots remain possible in theory but unlikely in practice.

American Idol Katy Perry: A Seven-Season Timeline

Five milestones mark the arc from revival anchor to departure.

The timeline shows Perry’s calculated exit, with major life events—album release and world tour—following immediately after her final Idol episode.

Related reading: Why did Katy Perry leave American Idol? · American Idol judges salary

On American Idol, Perry once encouraged contestant Benson Boone Idol exit after predicting his win, foreshadowing her own shift back to music pursuits.

Frequently Asked Questions